False Advertising Lawsuit Focuses on Section 230 Protections: Navigating the Boundaries of Online Accountability
, by Planet Green, 2 min reading time
California - 9/6/2023 — Planet Green Cartridges, Inc., a U.S. printer cartridge recycler and remanufacture, filed a $500 million lawsuit against tech giant Amazon. The lawsuit alleges that Amazon has engaged in false advertising and unfair competition by participating in the sale of newly manufactured clone printer ink cartridges that are deceptively marketed as "remanufactured" and misrepresented as eco-friendly recycled products.
Read: Planet Green v. Amazon, Case Number 2:23-cv-06647.
At the heart of this legal dispute is Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which grants internet companies immunity from legal liability for content posted by third parties. The main issue revolves around Planet Green's repeated requests for Amazon to police its platform and remove sellers falsely marketing and selling their products. Amazon invoked Section 230 immunity claims to any liability to the plaintiffs' claims.
"This lawsuit challenges Amazon's interpretation of Section 230 as the company actively participates in the sale of illicit cartridges, a direct violation of Section 5 of the FTC Act. The evidence presented by my client underscores Amazon's pivotal role in the distribution and sale of counterfeit recycled products, rendering the e-commerce giant accountable for these illicit items," asserts Attorney John Ulin, representing Planet Green.
In 2021, 75% of new sellers on Amazon originated from China, as many manufacturers find it easy to go direct-to-consumers through the online platform (Marketplace Pulse). This broad immunity poses a significant challenge when attempting to hold overseas sellers liable or accountable for unlawful and anti-competitive behavior according to U.S. law.
Planet Green CEO, Sean Levi observes, “This case should bring scrutiny from the FTC and lawmakers regarding how Section 230 is applied to ecommerce platforms. Our hope is an outcome that will reshape the dynamics of online shopping by holding e-commerce websites responsible for the products sold on their platforms.”
The lawsuit has been formally filed in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California and represents a critical facet of Planet Green's broader initiatives to reduce plastic waste, protect the environment, and promote a circular economy. To learn more and get involved, visit https://www.gofundme.com/f/Accountability-Together-We-Can-Make-A-Difference .
About Planet Green:
Established in 1999, Planet Green, located in Chatsworth, California, is one of the last remaining printer cartridge recyclers and remanufacturers in the U.S. The business is focused on diverting used printer cartridges from landfills and remanufacturing them for resale as an environmentally friendly and economical alternative. To learn more, visit planetgreenrecycle.com
Tags
Other Blog Posts
-
E-Waste’s Forgotten Kid: Why Ink & Toner Cartridges Matter
When people talk about e-waste, the conversation usually centers on big-ticket items: cell phones, laptops, televisions, or kitchen appliances. But one of the most common...
-
How Much is Too Much? The Carbon and Resource Cost of New Cartridges
Most people see a printer cartridge as a small, everyday item. But behind that small piece of plastic is a surprisingly large environmental cost. Every...
-
Cartridges in the Circular Economy: Challenges & Opportunities
The phrase “circular economy” has become a buzzword in sustainability circles, but what does it really mean? In simple terms, it’s about designing products and...
-
From Your Desk to the Return Label: The Rise of Mail-In Cartridge Recycling
For years, recycling ink cartridges often meant relying on office collection bins, retail drop-off points, or corporate programs tied to large accounts. But as more...
